Third Quarter — Still at the Bottom of the “L”

Morris Segall      2009 economy, business landscape, consumers, economy, government, slowdown

I continue to be surprised at the over-optimism of the mainstream financial press and government spokespeople on the current economic environment which is leading to increased forecasts of economic recovery beginning as early as this year’s third quarter.

Headlines indicating some economic improvement from higher consumer sentiment readings, a guarded optimistic reading on the economy from the Federal Reserve Open Market Committee this past week, a marginal improvement in the rate of economic decline in this year’s first quarter GDP and an impressive growth in the Advance report on Manufacturers Factory Orders for May were used as the basis for this continued optimism and a reversal in the stock market slide of the week before.

So once again I must put the facts on the table:

1. The fractional improvement in first quarter from -5.7% to -5.5% was entirely due to a smaller reduction in business inventories. In fact, consumer spending was actually reduced from a 1.3% gain to .95% thus shading the contribution from consumer improvement.

2. The strong improvement in Manufacturers Factory Orders in May is up only 1.5%, excluding transportation (primarily commercial aircraft), from the severely depressed level of March and is down 23% from May, 2008 levels. More importantly, the book/bill ratio of orders versus shipments in May was 95% versus approximately 96% in March and April. Thus non-transportation factory orders are no better and in some respects worse than they were at the end of depressed first quarter levels.

3. The Federal Reserve statement, while expressing guarded optimism that the worst of the economic contraction was behind us, kept interest rates at essentially 0% because the economy is still functioning at a depressed level.

4. On Friday, the government reported a surge in consumer incomes in May of 1.4% fed largely by government social security stimulus checks. On the other hand, consumer spending in May increased only .3% and the personal savings rate increased to 6.9%, a 15 year high. This low level of spending and the further increase in consumer savings on top of already historically high levels tells us the consumer is still very much concerned about the current economic environment, refuting his statements on consumer surveys, and is not ready to start pulling us out of recession by a surge in spending.

In our blog posting, “Beware Over-Exuberant Reactions to this Week’s Economic News,” (May 28, 2009), we stated “the second and third quarters of this year will be “less worse” than the first quarter but not an end to the recession”. We characterize the current economic environment as the bottom of an “L”. We have been projecting second quarter GDP to contract 2%-3% but with the continued weakness in consumer spending through May, GDP contraction in Q2 could reach 4%. Furthermore, we see little evidence that consumer spending will miraculously turn higher in Q3, particularly with continued high levels of unemployment which we expect will go higher over the summer spurred by layoffs from GM and Chrysler. Thus at this juncture, we expect Q3 GDP to be in a range of 0% to down 2%-3% depending on the level of U.S. government spending in the quarter. This is well below the 1%-3% growth in third quarter GDP many economists are currently projecting. If we are right, stock markets here and around the world are setting themselves up for a material correction from the elevated levels achieved this week.

An economic recovery will occur and we still believe it is largely a 2010 event but the continuation of the current economic torpor is pushing the recovery further into next year. We continue to be vigilant for real indications of a sustainable improvement in consumer spending which is a prerequisite to any recovery from this recession.

Morris R. Segall, CFA, CIC