Healthcare Reform and the Democrats: We have seen the enemy and they are us!

Morris Segall      Blue Dog Democrats, democrats, economics, economy, healthcare plan, healthcare reform, obama, republicans

As I feared from the beginning, the future of President Obama’s proposals were going to be in the hands of conservative or “Blue Dog” Democrats largely from the south, west and midwest. Their opposition to the high costs of the plan and a large federal presence in the system was going to be the defeat of the President’s program, rather than the expected “knee jerk” Republican opposition. The Republicans are now a marginal party lacking numbers and influence in the Congress to pass or defeat any legislation. It now appears the “Blue Dogs” will win out and “water down” the President’s plan to the point where it will be largely a failure in terms of progressive healthcare reform. It will eliminate a federal entity to offer insurance in competition to the private insurance industry. It will exempt thousands of so called small businesses, even those with payrolls of $500,000. It will also extract higher health insurance premiums on low-middle income wage earners. And most egregiously, push more of the increased Medicaid burden on the states who are already facing massive budget deficits and have no money to pay for anything. As a result of the “Blue Dog” opposition, in conjunction with the negative statements from the Republicans and the propaganda from the healthcare industry, popular support for the President’s program has been seriously eroded and the fact that Congress will adjourn for the month of August without passing healthcare reform legislation will give the President’s opponents an entire month to erode popular support further and “gut” the pending bills in committees even more.

I fear the final result will be little if any real healthcare reform; increased premiums for insured’s, particularly if private insurance firms have to accept less healthy members; and a continued increase in uninsured people as businesses are exempt from providing mandatory healthcare coverage. The winners will be the insurance and pharmaceutical industries who will have “dodged” a bullet for massive healthcare overhaul and reform. The costs to them will be a fraction of what the President’s program would have cost them and they will make it up by charging higher prices to the public. The losers will be the public who will continue to pay more for an unworkable system and doctors who will get paid less in an effort to control healthcare costs. By the way, the cost saving from the current compromise plan agreed to by the Democrats in the House is  $100 billion, the amount we sunk into General Motors and Chrysler in a futile attempt to save them from bankruptcy. As I said in my previous piece, it would appear we are more prone to spending billions saving corporate America than insuring the health of the American public.

The Democratic Party offered the American public comprehensive healthcare reform in the last two elections and the American public gave the Democratic Party the electoral majority they needed to get it done. It appears the Democrats decided that was a promise they are not willing to keep.

Morris R. Segall

Recommended reading:

Turning the Corner: GDP, Housing and Cash for Clunkers

An Open Letter to Congress

—–