Happy Days Are Here Again: But How Happy and for How Long?
The March monthly unemployment report was the latest in a series of positive economic reports that confirms an expansion in the economic recovery. Since late February, we have observed a perceptible pick-up in consumer spending since the end of the severe winter weather. We have noticed an increase in traffic in restaurants and malls and have heard firsthand of increased travel by consumers. This empirical data has been confirmed by reports from major retailers and cruise ship lines over the past two weeks of increased revenues in the month of March. The spring thaw has unleashed pent up spending which we have expected would spur a real economic recovery when the unemployment situation improved. While we believe new job losses have peaked, we have stated in previous comments that the chronic level of long term unemployment and the suppressed level of wage and salary income growth would be depressants to increased consumer spending. Despite repeated evidence that the level of long term unemployment is not improving, consumers are apparently satisfied with their financial conditions to allow an increase in discretionary spending. Combined with a continued surge in factory orders from businesses and rising exports, we expect first quarter GDP to be a solid 3% based on a strong March performance and the second quarter could be even stronger with growth in the 4%-6% range based on:
1. A strong rebound in housing to take advantage of the extended home buyer tax credit set to expire in June. We would not be surprised to see that credit extended again to compensate for the lost time in January and February due to harsh winter weather.
2. An increase in auto sales as replacement demand increases due to the extended age of the automobile fleet and the detrimental impact on cars from this winter’s weather.
3. Continued and broader increases in capital equipment orders from businesses that are seeing increased sales, pent-up demand for capital equipment and rising corporate profits.
4. Increasing exports to fast growing and recovering overseas economies.
5. Increased federal spending from the accelerated release of stimulus funds.
If our projections are correct, strong consumer spending in the second quarter will lead to an inventory replacement cycle in the third quarter and increased industrial production from building backlogs. We do not foresee a double dip recession in the second half of this year.
However, we do expect a slowdown in GDP growth in the second half because the current surge in consumer spending cannot be sustained under current employment and consumer income conditions. We expect the current increase in consumer spending will come from savings and reduced reduction in consumer debt. While that helps spending in the short term it is cause for concern longer term. We have consistently commented in our posted economic presentations that a consistent effort on the part of American consumers to save more and reduce debt results in a healthier, more consistent and more creditworthy consumer that can sustain an increasing level of economic growth. Thus, while the industrial sector and exports can keep economic growth going through this year, reduced federal subsidy programs and lower levels of consumer spending make the economic outlook for 2011 more difficult to predict. Furthermore, commodity and energy prices are already on the rise which will increase inflation going forward and we expect the Fed will have to raise interest rates by this summer. The confluence of rising prices and interest rates will put additional pressure on consumer incomes and spending.
So while the economy is improving, sustained recovery still needs permanent job creation and the absorption of the large pool of long term unemployed.
Morris R. Segall, CFA, CIC
SPG Trend Advisors is a boutique consultancy that provides global economic research for business and other decision makers. With fifty years combined experience between the principals, and through its website, SPG Trend Advisors provides insightful analysis and forecasting to prepare senior executives for tomorrows trends. Visit 
