The Economy, Capital Markets, Healthcare and Geopolitical Events

Morris Segall      2009 economy, Capital Markets, Cash for Clunkers, economics, Geopolitical, healthcare plan, trends, unemployment

Today the government released its third and final revision to the second quarter GDP numbers and shaved the 1% contraction to .7%. There were no major shifts in trends from the previous report but the positive direction of business fixed investment and consumer spending was aided by a surge in government spending, as expected. As we have stated previously, it appears the recession ended in the second quarter. Led by rising home and auto sales, positive trends in industrial production and retail sales continued through July.

The expectation was for these trends to continue through August and into September led by continued government stimulus and subsidy programs. However, August numbers for existing and new home sales declined in August from July levels and factory orders for durable goods in August were also unexpectedly down from July levels. This makes us uneasy about the underlying improvement in the economy. We have stated previously that government stimulus and subsidy programs, notably the “Cash for Clunkers” program and the tax credit for first time home buyers, were likely to spur positive GDP growth in the third and fourth quarters of this year. The question in our mind was what happens when those programs expire. Now we see that despite the positive demand stimulus from the government programs and the momentum of increased home sales and prices and auto sales in June and July, there was no follow through in August. And there should have been. The decline in factory orders is particularly disturbing because the positive trend in auto and home sales should be leading to a steady improvement in factory orders and production to replace goods sold.

The decline in many of the components of the factory orders report suggest that businesses are not ready to ready to begin a sustained capital spending uptrend. If they are not going to increase spending with government stimulus, what happens when that stimulus ends. It will be very important to see housing and business spending levels for September and the remainder of this year to gauge whether we are really in recovery or facing a downleg in the “W” shaped economic outlook we raised in our August 3rd blog entry, “Turning the Corner…“. While the “Clunker” program has expired we expect the current home buyer tax credit program to be extended into next year given the success of that program.

Today also marks the end of the third quarter and stock markets around the world concluded one of the most successful quarters in decades. The Dow Jones Industrial Average gained 15% in the quarter and overseas markets showed bigger increases including Europe and Japan as well as emerging markets. Fed by infusions of liquidity from central banks and the specter of worldwide economic recoveries, capital markets surged. In recent weeks, increased speculation and appetite for risk have reappeared in debt and banking transaction markets. Year to date the Dow is up 50% from its March lows. Overseas markets show comparable and greater gains. But at this point both bond and stock markets here and abroad are stretched and need further evidence of economic and corporate profit improvements to protect present gains and sustain additional appreciation. If the outlook for worldwide economic growth proves correct we believe worldwide debt markets are vulnerable to declines from higher interest rates next year from the current depressed levels. Here again, economic data over the remainder of this year will influence the direction of worldwide capital markets. If our concern over a “W” shaped economic outlook proves correct, expect a major correction in U.S. and overseas markets from current levels. We are watching developments closely.

In our blog entry, “Healthcare Reform and the Democrats…“, of August 6, we raised concerns over passage of the President’s healthcare proposal and the split in the Democratic Party that we felt would be the undoing of the President’s plan. Events since then have validated that concern and it now appears that for the same $1 trillion price tag Congress will pass a healthcare bill that omits a public option. This will leave the private healthcare and pharmaceutical industries intact and escaping significant third party competition. The political “fallout” is considerable. The President is wounded and his party is split. There is concern about Democratic Party losses in next year’s Congressional elections as the debate over healthcare reform has been framed as big government socialism versus libertarian, individual democracy. A perceived defeat of the President and a fractious Democratic Party will have international implications as both our allies and foes evaluate the strength of this President.

Speaking of geopolitics, this weekend’s victory of Angela Merkel in German elections lends further support to our contention that Europeans are turning to the political “right” (See our website article, “I am Mad as Hell…“, March 23, 2009). Running on a pro business, lower tax platform, Chancellor Merkel and a right of center, pro business party won nearly 50% of the popular vote. The long time Social Democratic Party garnered less than 25% of the popular vote, its worst defeat in postwar history. Angela Merkel joins Nicholas Sarkozy of France heading a center right European government and the victory of center right parties in this year’s European Parliament elections. Furthermore, it is widely believed Britons will elect a Conservative government in next year’s elections. The disillusionment of European voters with socialist governments is the direct result of the economic damage to those electorates from the recession and the increase in protectionist sentiments to protect domestic jobs and incomes.

Additionally, geopolitical events from Afghanistan to Honduras are hurting President Obama and his foreign policy agenda. The President is in danger of being viewed as impotent and more style than substance. While he remains very popular overseas, his policies and lack of forceful actions in the face of antagonistic behavior will erode his ability to lead a free world coalition against rising threats. We will publish on our website in the near future an in depth analysis of international events and the Obama foreign policy.

In summary, as we conclude the third quarter recent economic data is disquieting and if continued will threaten the outlook for economic recovery in the U.S. and the large gains in worldwide capital markets achieved to date. Overseas events also threaten to undermine the “honeymoon” in foreign affairs enjoyed by President Obama to date. We are not changing our intermediate and longer term positive economic and capital markets outlooks at this point but we are watching data and events over the next three months very carefully.

Morris R. Segall, CFA, CIC

Economic and Capital Market Update

Morris Segall      2009 economy, business landscape, Cash for Clunkers, consumers, economics, recession, trends

It looks like it is all falling into place. Improved housing sales, increased factory orders and shipments, the “Cash for Clunkers” program moving autos off of dealer lots and stimulating increased automobile factory production and the best news of all, stock markets around the world are hitting 12 month highs. World central bankers, including our own Ben Bernanke, pronounce the recession over as GDP for the June quarters show positive growth in France, Germany, Japan and most of Asia. The capital markets buying the rumor are soaring fed by huge amounts of liquidity added to monetary systems by the world central banks as they embarked on economic bailout and stimulus programs. This past Friday’s U.S. stock market action has typified the recent ebullience among bankers and investors. The Dow Jones Industrial Average breached the 9500 level for the first time since last October buoyed by further good news in existing home sales and Ben Bernanke’s positive comments.

Continue reading this premium article at spgtrend.com

The July Monthly Employment Report: More Good News But…

Morris Segall      2009 economy, Cash for Clunkers, consumer credit, economic, employment report, Establishment Survey, Federal Reserve, government, unemployment

On Friday, the Labor Department reported the monthly employment situation report for the month of July. The Establishment Survey, the one most widely used as the benchmark for measuring monthly job creation showed nonfarm payroll employment declined by 247,000 in the month of July, a number better than widely held forecasts. It is the lowest level of monthly job losses since last August before the massive economic declines in the fourth quarter of last year and the first quarter of this year. It is also two thirds lower than the peak level of monthly job losses recorded in January of this year at over 740,000. With a number this low, naturally job losses in most major industry sectors measured by the survey saw significant declines in job losses from the surprisingly weak June levels. The exception was retail trade which saw job losses in this category double from 21,000 in June to 44,000 in July reflecting the continued poor consumer spending environment. Nonetheless, economists and financial commentators viewed the dramatic improvement in the monthly numbers as further evidence of the recession’s end and imminent economic recovery. To be sure, we concur the huge decline in monthly job losses reported since March’s 652,000 follows the general trend in first time unemployment claims which peaked at 674,000 in late March and has declined to 550,000 as of August 1st and signifies a peaking in new job destruction in this cycle and fortifies other economic data suggesting the recession has bottomed.

However, as we have written in previous posts, “Current Economic News Needs a Dose of Reality“, May 15th, 2009, the dramatically improved job loss numbers in the government’s Establishment Survey continues to be at odds with other government employment reports and empirical data we are getting from job seekers and businesses. Inconsistencies include:

1. While job losses in July measured 247,000 and a 9.4% unemployment rate, the civilian  labor force saw over 400,000 people leave it in July versus June and over 570,000 since May. The civilian labor force participation rate in July fell to 65.5%, matching the lowest level of worker participation in this cycle in March of this year.

2. While monthly job losses per the Establishment Survey have declined from 652,000 in March to 247,000 in July, first time unemployment claims, representing new job layoffs, have declined from 674,000 to 550,000 over the same period. A figure twice as high as the establishment survey estimate.

3. The number of unemployed workers including discouraged workers and part time workers who cannot get full time employment continued to increase in July. The number of people leaving or not in the work force increased substantially (over 1 million people) in July reflecting discouragement with finding gainful employment. This is consistent with the empirical information we hear from job seekers who say jobs are very hard to land and employers who tell us they are still not hiring and will have to lay off more workers if sales do not pick up.

4. The average work week increased by .1% to 33.1, the second lowest work week during the entire recession. We will see if the recent three month trend of monthly job losses per the Establishment Survey of approximately 330,000 is accurate. We continue to believe these recent numbers are vulnerable to downward revision when the Labor
Department makes it annual benchmark revisions next March. For now, the consensus is taking the numbers at face value.

There was another very important economic announcement on Friday. The Federal Reserve released its report on Consumer Credit for the month of June and for the fourth consecutive quarter, consumer credit declined. Consumer credit contracted at nearly a 5% annual rate in June, nearly double the 2.6% annual rate of decline in May. Since its peak in the third quarter of 2008, consumer credit outstanding has declined 3% or over $75 billion at the end of June, 2009. Most of this decline has occurred in revolving credit, i.e. credit cards. Since the third quarter of 2008, revolving credit has declined 6% or over $55 billion. Clearly consumers are continuing to pay down their debt in an attempt to de-leverage their balance sheets. Combined with a continued high savings rate in excess of 4% at the end of the second quarter, it is clear American consumers are paying down debt and increasing their liquidity. These trends and the existing high levels of unemployment continue to suppress consumer spending.

The government is artificially creating increased consumer spending and retail sales via its “Cash for Clunkers” program and the other stimulus package spending that will be impacting the economy over the next four quarters. However without job creation rather than “less worse” job destruction, a sustained consumer led spending increase is unlikely. In fact, to the extent the government creates consumer spending near term, it could result in deflated consumer spending longer term when the government stimulus ends. The key to a real economic recovery continues to be the revival and return of the consumer, with a job and the financial capacity and creditworthiness to spend. The consumer led us into the recession. He will have to lead us out. Recovery in this cycle was always going to be a long stretch in re-liquifying and de-leveraging the consumer so he could “get back in the game”. He is doing just that but the loss of his job is making those tasks longer and more difficult. While these trends hurt the economy in the short term, they will help sustain the recovery in the longer term.

Morris R. Segall, CFA, CIC

Turning the Corner: GDP, Housing and Cash for Clunkers

Morris Segall      2009 economy, Cash for Clunkers, consumers, economics, GDP, government, housing

Friday’s news of the “less worse” second quarter GDP was received as another piece of good news by the stock market as further evidence of the end of the recession. It capped a week of improving economic news on housing. But the real economic sweetener that offers a tangible boost to the economy in the near term was the announcement on Friday that the government’s “Cash for Clunkers” program was extended by the House of Representatives and augmented by a further $2 Billion in government funds.

Of all of the various government schemes and bailout programs to stimulate the economy over the past two years, the government finally got it right with this one. We have stated repeatedly, the economy was not going to recover until the consumer started moving “goods off the shelves”. Well goods are moving off the shelves or rather cars are flying off of car dealers lots. OK  the U.S. government is buying the cars but the end result is dealers are emptying their inventories and will soon reorder from the factories as long as the government program is in force. The Senate needs to also approve the program’s extension or it will expire by the end of this week. We are optimistic the Senate will vote to continue the program before they adjourn this Friday. This will in turn start the manufacturing replacement cycle. The “Cash for Clunkers” program is expected to increase retail sales beginning in July, increase industrial production by the fourth quarter and even help factory employment due to the higher production rates. Higher auto production will have a widespread positive impact on manufacturing and distribution sectors. It is our belief this program will insure a positive growth in U.S. GDP in both the third and fourth quarters of this year. Now let’s be clear. This is artificial consumption and will deflate when this program expires which we assume will be at year end. We don’t think Congress will ante any more money for this when the current funding is used up. By that time, the rest of the economy may be starting to fill in the void .

To that end, we are seeing for the first time a trend of positive news on housing that would support our long standing forecast of a bottoming in the housing cycle in the second half of this year and obviously remove a major depressant to the economy. This past week both new and existing home sales rose for the third month in a row. And for the first time since the housing market imploded, home prices showed a monthly increase according to the widely followed Case-Shiller Home Price Index. In addition, inventories of existing and new homes are now getting down to normalized levels. Here again, the recovery process is not widespread and is largely centered in homes in the $150,000-$300,000 price range as home buyers take advantage of bargain prices, ample supply and willing sellers in the deflated housing market.

Lastly, the second quarter GDP was reported with a contraction of 1%. While this was better than consensus economic forecasts including our own, it is the first of three readings on the quarter and the one subject to the most revision as more data is processed over the next month. The second reading on the quarter will be reported at the end of August and will be more definitive. While the report was mixed with continuing depressants in consumer spending and business fixed investment, the quarter saw the beginnings of increased government spending which helped offset the weakness in consumption and business investment. Nonetheless, the quarter fulfilled our forecast of a decidedly “less worse” performance than the severe contraction of the first quarter. Importantly, the huge decline in business fixed investment appears to have bottomed in the second quarter and will not be the huge depressant on the economy going forward.

So for the following reasons we now believe the third and fourth quarters of this year will show positive growth though we are not forecasting an economy embarking on a full recovery. Unemployment is still too high and there is a great deal of unutilized production capacity that will keep private sector spending suppressed. However, the bulk of the government stimulus spending will hit the economy in the next four quarters providing a strong plus for GDP growth and exports are picking up from rising economic growth in Asia led by China. These pluses along with reduced minuses from consumption and business fixed investment should equate to positive GDP growth in the second half. The question is can the private sector recover on its own without the huge and finite pull of the federal government. The answer remains the level of unemployment and consumer incomes.

As the macro economic environment improves, the outlook for corporate profit growth also improves providing further stimulus to rising stock markets here and abroad. The likelihood of a sizable correction in the equity markets is diminishing the further we go through this year and into next. We have long been bullish on equities over the 2010-2012 period and increased equity allocations in our capital markets strategy this past spring once a bottom in the recession was perceptible. We have hit that bottom and reaffirm our longer term capital markets strategy of getting fully invested in U.S. and overseas equities with a strong allocation to commodities, including gold.

Morris R. Segall, CFA, CIC