May Unemployment Disappoints; So does Europe

Morris Segall      capital markets strategies, Economic Growth, European sovereign debt, May unemployment, stock market

Friday’s unemployment report for May was just what the stock market didn’t need- a disappointing jobs creation picture. Total nonfarm payrolls grew by a little over 400,000 in the month of May, but virtually all of that increase was due to temporary hires for the U.S. Census. Most of those workers will be terminated by the end of the summer. Only 41,000 jobs were created in the private sector in May according to the business establishment survey, well below the 150,000+ jobs expected. We have been commenting in previous blog postings about the increasing inaccuracy of the monthly business establishment survey in reporting job creation. Most of our criticism has been focused on the erroneous seasonal adjustments and the errors in reporting job creation in the small business sector. Most of the monthly reporting errors result in overstating job creation that are then reversed when the Labor Dept. makes its semiannual revisions in the winter and summer of each year. However, this time we believe the May jobs report is actually understating job creation. Empirical data and other employment measures point to a larger job creation in May than the 41,000 reported on Friday. We believe the May number will be revised upward in subsequent monthly reports over the summer. But that is where the good news on jobs ends. First time unemployment claims are “stuck”  around 450,000, far too high to indicate strong  job creation. In addition, other measures in the May jobs report continue to point to high levels of discouraged and underemployed workers and most discomforting,  a continued high level, nearly 50%,  of workers unemployed are jobless for 27 weeks and longer. We estimate that we are building a “hard core” unemployment rate of over 6% as a result of the recession and the historically weak economic recovery.

Also on Friday was news from Hungary that their fiscal situation was becoming dire to the point of possible debt default. The announcement was a surprise since it was assumed the IMF bailout of Hungary last year was sufficient to avoid default. The prospect of another European country sliding toward debt default was sufficient to break the euro below critical levels of $1.20 on Friday and raise the threat levels again of more widespread financial crisis in Europe. The Hungarian announcement created new strains on the financial system in Europe with lending spreads and costs of credit default insurance rising again. The situation in Europe is becoming more alarming as default risks spread from Southern Europe to Central Europe and likely to Eastern Europe next. The austerity programs being enacted by the governments in Southern and Western Europe and the U.K. will exacerbate the problems in Central and Eastern Europe that depend on exports to the Eurozone for much of their GDP growth. The financial system is now on heightened alert again to see where this latest emergency in Europe will lead. The outlook for containing the European sovereign debt problems is becoming more bleak.

The combination of a weak employment report and the dire news from Hungary, reversed a stock market rally that began before Memorial Day and carried strongly through last Thursday. The market decline on Friday eroded market technicals and has cast doubt on the view that the market decline in May was a correction and not more serious. We have stated in our most recent blog entries that we believe the market action in May signals a “Sea Change” in the international capital markets cycle. The market action on Friday confirms that view for us. We now believe we are moving towards a short-intermediate term trading range on the Dow 30 Industrials of between 9,000-11,000. We reiterate our belief that the market highs recorded at the end of April-early May, are the highs for this market cycle. While the U.S. economic news has been improving since last summer, going forward, the economic news becomes more problematic as Federal stimulus recedes and the stock market itself becomes the main story in the economy. It is estimated a trillion dollars of market value was lost in the month of May and June is extending that. The market decline is replacing risk assumption with risk aversion and when investors see their portfolio values at the end of May, there is the fear consumer spending will retrench just when the economy needs more robust consumer spending. We believe it is possible the pace of the U.S. economic recovery could be retarded by the current stock market decline. We  continue to stress defensiveness in our capital market strategies and emphasize U.S. dollar denominated assets.

Morris R. Segall, CFA, CIC