Third Quarter GDP Revised Down

Morris Segall      2009 economy, consumers, economics, future trends, GDP, global, government, recession, stimulas, unemployment

Yesterday’s second reading on the third quarter GDP showed a downward revision from the robust 3.5% preliminarily reported at the end of October. As November wore on expectations of the second and more definitive read on the third quarter was for a downward revision to the 3% level but no one was alarmed. It was considered more or less statistical.

After taking a look at the revisions from the preliminary report we are concerned for the following reasons:

1. Personal consumption was revised down from 3.4% growth to 2.9% with spending on goods dropping from 8.1% growth to 7.2%.
2. Business capital spending dropped from 11.5% growth  in  the preliminary report to 8.4% in the revision with large downward revisions in the growth of inventories and business structures.
3. Federal government spending growth was revised upward from  2.3%  to  3.1%.
4. Growth in final sales of domestic product was revised downward from 2.5% to 1.9%.

This revised mix of weakness in business and consumer spending with all of the federal government stimulus in the quarter is alarming and casts further doubt on the underlying strength in the economy as federal stimululs abates going into next year. Our assumption of 1%-3% GDP growth in the fourth quarter will need strong contributions in both consumer and business fixed investment from the revised third quarter levels. We detect an improved level of retail sales in the quarter but  will need to see sales results of “Black Friday” to see if that is true. A disappointment in this weekend’s sales will cause a shift in outlook for both the economy and particularly the capital markets which have been seeing the glass “half full” in November despite the warning signs in consumer sentiment, new home sales and continued high levels of unemployment. It is noteworthy that the market gains in November have been accompanied by low levels of trading volume, an ominous sign for sustained capital market gains.

In our previous website and blog articles on the preliminary third quarter GDP, we remained skeptical of the durability of the third quarter gains and said we would be watching fourth quarter economic data closely for future direction. With the downward revision in third quarter numbers, we will be even more vigilant to see if this economic recovery has “legs”.
Best wishes for a Happy Thanksgiving holiday and stay tuned.

Morris R. Segall, CFA, CIC